Mada su vecina osvrti i samo prvi gore moze proci kao konkretnija recenzija, svejedno dobar posao Segregator.
Zbilja ima malo opipljivijeg info-a ne Web-u o njima.
Zanimljiviji su pojedinacni komentari korisnika.
Oni koji kritiziraju obicno daju vrlo konkretne razloge i kredibilno potkepljuju preciznim razlozima, dok oni koji su sretni obicno sve sumiraju epitetima kako je zvuk prostran
Evo par po meni najboljih, koji odlicno opisuju realnost.
Posebno prvi, jer trezveno razmislja i kao da me podpisuje.
___________________________________________
01 >
Reviewer: RC (Canada)
I was shopping around for a high end 2.1 multimedia set and it came down to the following 3 sets: Logitech z2200, Bose Compnion 3 and Altec Lansing MX5021.
The Bose set is definately the most stylish of the three as well as it takes the least amount of space. But the price (which is twice as much as the other two sets) is a great fault. Yes, they are loud and clear but compared to the other 2 sets, the sound is colored and certain frequencies are simply "not there". It should be espected since the Companion 3 system probably uses similar drivers as Bose's Acoustimass speakers (2" mid/high and 5.25" bass driver). When compared to other ($50 range) low end speakers, the Bose set will astonish you, however put it beside the Logitech set & you will notice a huge difference. Bose is great at producing PLEASANT (but not accurate) sound. The Altec MX5021 had the best overall clarity and neutrality of the 3.
All it comes down to is an individual's sound preference. I would give a listen to all 3 and make a chioce afterwards. Bose looks good but the puny 5.25" bass driver cannot compete with Logitech 8" 120W driver. Altec's 3 way stellites are 3 times bigger & give you much clearer & open sound.
For under $150 I would buy the Companion 3 and keep it. But when the competitors are offering better produts at half the price, there's no reason for spending that much uless you're really dying to have the name Bose on your desktop.
___________________________________________
02>
Reviewer: mrmike (Texas, USA)
I would rate this system as average to poor. The speakers provide ample bass but other frequencies sound cheap. It helps if you update your sound card drivers, experiment with plug-ins and equalizer settings if you use WinAmp but nevertheless, it's a major tweaking job. I may be too picky but I expected better sound quality for the price.
The system looks good and the mouse-type volume control/mute/headphone jack/input jack is a good idea. Bottomline, don't buy this system if you're a perfectionist about sound reproduction.
___________________________________________
03>
Reviewer: Dallas Electronics Fan (Dallas,TX.)
not even a reasonably accurate midrange. Shame on the Bose corporation for marketing yet another overpriced, under performing product. I would encourage anyone in the market for a good pair of desktop speakers to listen to the brands I list at the top of this review. The quality of desktop speakers has risen to a very high level in the last couple of years. Amazingly, the Bose corporation's arrogance has once again produced yet another embarrasing product.
___________________________________________
04>
Reviewer: Bruce Wine (Chicago,IL)
Well, the time when BOSE name was associated with good sound came and gone. As for now it is company who sells crappy speakers for reach guys. In fact you can get the speaker s that sound much better for third of the price but they will not be such beautifully slick. For the price you can get pro sound from Samson, M-Audio, Fostex Alesis studio monitors. This set has bad everything. It has dirty bass, poor midrange (near not midrange) and flat and dull highs. Yes it is slick, but there's no sound.
To have the sound you need the space where the sound could resonate, that's why people buy larger speakers with invertors. It is simple like that: no resonance - no sound! If you have the extra money to show off with BOSE brand buy those. But do not forget to save some money to buy a good speakers along to listen to music after your friends will read the label.
___________________________________________
05>
Reviewer: Mark Gibson (San Francisco, CA United States
These speakers are terrible. I assumed -- unwisely -- that given the Bose brand and high price tag, that the sound quality would be wonderful, or at least average. As the other reviewers have noted, the midrange on these speakers are terrible -- a full 1/3 of the sound is missing: e.g., background vocals are frequently inaudible.
The industrial design is beautiful, and the interface is friendly, but not worth the extra cost. For audio purists and anyone who wants value for their money, you'd be better off with another speaker system.
___________________________________________
06>
Reviewer: "ms61" (Ft.Collins CO. USA)
Bose a highly respected name in speakers is taking advantage of that. When I first got my speakers I thought they were pretty good. However as time went on they have gotten worse and worse. The sattelites have stated an irratating buzz wich can be heard over the music. The bass is awesome but the sattelites leave much to be desired. I also know i havent blown them and it is not my sound card. My final thought is that if your going to spend $250 on speakers get somethig else.